Saturday
Night
LiveFantasy

Season totals in this recap include the Nov 7 corrections to Episodes 1–4 (cast totals 136, 138, 163 and 174).

For the first time this season, the top of the box score is a tie. James Austin Johnson and Jeremy Culhane both finished with 19 points, and they got there in opposite ways. JAJ banked 15 before the monologue: Trump in the post-midterm cold open, plus a shared "Live from New York" with Senator-elect James Talarico. Culhane spread his across the whole night, from JD Vance in the cold open to Elon Musk at the Update desk to the rejected boyfriend in Proposal.

The night's biggest fantasy play was the New Health Tracker pre-tape. Druski's My Corner Guy ad put seven cast members on camera with lines, and every one of them banked 2 points. Andrew Dismukes rode that ad, a rap verse in Proposal and a return of the Two People Who Just Hooked Up to 16, his best night of the season.

Mikey Day had a quieter week. He scored 7 across four segments, his lowest total of the season, and JAJ's lead over him grew from 18 points to 30. The cast combined for 155 points, down 19 from Halloween but still the third-best total of the season.

Box score

Five cast members were in the cold open, and four of them cashed a recurring impression. Fourteen of the 17 cast members appeared in at least three segments.

(R) = rookie.

Host and musical guest. Druski scored 38: 20 for the pick, 9 for appearances and 9 for speaking in the monologue and eight sketches. His 18 non-pick points are the best by a Season 52 host. The Strokes scored the 20-point pick and nothing more; they played "Lonely in the Future" and "Going Shopping" but were not in a sketch. Drafting both was worth 58.

Settings (18 pts). Restaurant hit twice for 4 (Birthday Girl, Proposal). Golden Age of Hip Hop scored two settings, Historical and Film / TV Set, for its old crew footage and TV-studio framing. Talk Show (Washington in Focus), Film Parody and Living Room (Dru Can See Everything), Retail (the Bubu Mobile phone store) and Infomercial (the My Corner Guy ad) added 2 each.

Wild cards (30 pts). Celebrity cameo hit twice for 10: Emma Stone in the monologue, and Walton Goggins, who counts as a cameo because he played bongos with The Strokes during "Going Shopping." The celebrities who walked out for the goodnights (Dave Chappelle, Chris Rock, Michael B. Jordan and Austin Butler) do not count as cameos. Host sings outside the monologue also hit twice for 10, for Druski's "She Said Yes" number in Proposal and the rap crew in Golden Age of Hip Hop. Political cameo hit for the first time this season with Talarico in the cold open, and Food is central to a sketch hit for the sizzling fajitas in Birthday Girl.

Commissioner rulings. Kenan Thompson's Hakeem Jeffries is not a recurring character. Culhane spoke as JD Vance in the cold open and Belo-Osagie spoke as the bride in Wedding Photographers (+1 each). Marshall's ASL interpreter had no lines. There was no on-camera kiss in Wedding Photographers. Druski's bleeped profanity in the Dru Can See Everything pre-tape does not count as cursing on air. No one broke.

Co-MVPs: James Austin Johnson and Jeremy Culhane, 19 points each

James Austin Johnson did it with the cold open. Trump in the opener is worth 10 before anything else happens, and JAJ has now opened all five Season 52 shows. Sharing "Live from New York" with Talarico added 5, his third sign-off of the season, and he picked up the last 4 singing backup in Proposal and rapping in Golden Age of Hip Hop. He has topped or tied for the top of the box score in four of five weeks, and leads the season with 109.

Jeremy Culhane did it with volume. He scored in four categories: the cold open as JD Vance (recurring), three sketches with lines, and a new Elon Musk at the Update desk. It is his best total of the season by 7 points, and it moves him to 64, third overall.

Honorable mention: Andrew Dismukes, 16 points. From 2 on Halloween to 16. He hosted the 10-to-1 sketch, rapped a verse as Sherman's estranged dad in Proposal, appeared in the My Corner Guy ad, and earned the recurring bonus with Ashley Padilla at the desk.

Studs and duds

Studs

• Jeremy Culhane, 19 points. A share of the top spot and five segments, tied with Dismukes for the most in the cast.
• James Austin Johnson, 19 points. Five cold opens in five weeks.
• Andrew Dismukes, 16 points. His best night of the season, after a first-four high of 9.
• Sarah Sherman, 16 points. Her best total this season. The Chuck Schumer impression she first played in 2022 is back on the board.
• New Health Tracker owners. Seven cast members spoke in the ad, the biggest pre-tape payday of the season.
• Druski, 38 points. Nine segments and nine speaking parts, the most of any Season 52 host.

Duds

• Mikey Day, 7 points. Four segments but no cold open and no break bonus. He had scored 16, 8, 25 and 23.
• Kam Patterson, 2 points. Despite having worked with Druski before, he appeared only in the last sketch of the night.
• Veronika Slowikowska, 5 points. From 17 on Halloween to three segments, one of them without a line.
• The Strokes, 20 points. The pick and nothing else, the third Season 52 musical guest kept out of the sketches.

Trends: the season after five episodes

JAJ leads with 109 points. Mikey Day (79) is second but lost 12 points of ground in one week. Culhane (64) is third, Sherman (57) fourth and Padilla (53) fifth. Cast scoring has gone 136, 138, 163, 174 and now 155.

• It's still a JAJ-Day race, but Culhane is closing. Culhane gained 12 on Day this week and is 15 behind him.
• The cold open is the best weekly event. Three cast members in the premiere, then 7, 7, 9 and 5 this week. JAJ has been in all five.
• Political impressions keep paying. Four recurring bonuses came out of one cold open: Trump, Hegseth, Vance and Schumer.
• "Live from New York" is back with JAJ. He has said it in Episodes 1, 2 and 5; Jost had Episode 3, and Slowikowska and Day split Episode 4.
• Big pre-tapes spread the points. New Health Tracker put seven cast members on the board in one segment, and 14 of 17 cast members appeared at least three times.
• Hosts are trending up. Non-pick host points: Brunson 15, Johnson 14, Gillis 12, Navarrette 14, Druski 18.
• Musical guests are 2 for 5. KATSEYE and Rosalía appeared in sketches; Turnstile, Gracie Abrams and The Strokes did not.
• Wild cards stayed strong. 30 points, second only to Halloween's 45 (the first three weeks paid 15, 10 and 10). Celebrity cameo has hit in four of five episodes, Food is central in three straight, and Host sings outside the monologue in three of five.
• History note. Druski is the first host who built his career as an online content creator. The Strokes made their fifth appearance as musical guest; the last was in 2020, on an episode hosted by next week's host, John Mulaney.

Waiver wire: moves for Episode 6 (John Mulaney / Phoebe Bridgers)

• Start with confidence: James Austin Johnson. Five for five in the cold open.
• Start: Jeremy Culhane. JD Vance and a new Elon Musk give him two political characters that can return any week.
• Hold: Mikey Day. One quiet week does not erase a 72-point first four, and a seven-time host who used to write for the show tends to fill big ensemble sketches.
• Start: Sarah Sherman. Her Schumer is now in play whenever Democratic leadership is in the news.
• Pick up: Andrew Dismukes. The Two People Who Just Hooked Up can return any week the news cooperates.
• Hold: Colin Jost. Hegseth has carried him in three of five weeks.
• Bench: Kam Patterson and Michael Che until their usage changes.
• Wild cards: Celebrity cameo (four of five weeks) is still the best hold. Political cameo is live now that the new Congress is a running story.

Corrected Nov 5, 2026: Tommy Brennan appeared and spoke in the Delta Disruptive pre-tape (+2).

Corrected Nov 8, 2026: the commissioner's Nov 7 rulings added Jane Wickline to the cold open (no lines) and Kam Patterson to Delta Disruptive. The cast total is 174, and season totals include the corrections to Episodes 1–3.

The Halloween show came down to one point. James Austin Johnson finished with 24 and Mikey Day with 23, and the difference was a break late in the night. In PAW Patrol: Special Victims Unit, first-time host Inde Navarrette started cracking up as JAJ made his entrance as the villain. The commissioner ruled that JAJ caused the break: +10 for JAJ, −2 for Navarrette. It is the first break bonus this season that did not go to Mikey Day.

Day did nearly everything else right. He returned as one of David S. Pumpkins' dancing skeletons beside Tom Hanks and Bobby Moynihan, a role he first played in 2016, and it was ruled recurring for +5. He also shared "Live from New York" with Veronika Slowikowska after her Katie Zacharia fumbled the sign-off, and both of them got the 5 points.

The whole cast feasted. The 17 active cast members combined for 174 points, a new season high and 11 more than Episode 3. Wild cards paid out 45 points across six different cards, and three of them, Blood or vomit, Character death and A puppet appears on camera, were the Halloween picks from last week's waiver wire.

Box score

Nine cast members appeared in the cold open, the biggest of the season, and 13 cast members scored 6 or more, tying Episode 3 for the season high.

(R) = rookie.

Host and musical guest. Inde Navarrette scored 34: 20 for the pick, 8 for appearances and 8 for speaking, minus 2 for breaking in PAW Patrol: SVU. Gracie Abrams scored the 20-point pick and nothing more; she performed twice but did not appear in a sketch. Drafting both was worth 54.

Settings (14 pts). Seven settings hit for 2 each: Infomercial (the Delta Disruptive airline ad), Game Show (Uninterested Woman Game Show), Living Room and Laboratory (The Inventor's Wife, her home and his workshop), Film / TV Set (El Corazón Que No Siente, set during a telenovela taping), Film Parody (PAW Patrol: SVU) and Restaurant (Plates).

Wild cards (45 pts). Celebrity cameo hit twice for 10 (Tom Hanks in the cold open, three Milwaukee Brewers on Update). Former cast member cameo hit twice for 10 (Bobby Moynihan in the cold open and as Drunk Uncle on Update). Character death hit twice for 10 (The Inventor's Wife and PAW Patrol: SVU). Blood or vomit (The Inventor's Wife), A puppet appears on camera (PAW Patrol: SVU) and Food is central to a sketch (Plates) added 5 each. The monologue's cutaway to Navarrette's "boyfriend" in the audience did not count as a cameo.

MVP: James Austin Johnson, 24 points

JAJ is back on top after Mikey Day took Episode 3. Ten of his points came from one moment: Navarrette broke as he arrived as the PAW Patrol villain, the first time all season a cast member other than Day has cashed a break bonus.

The rest was his usual formula. Trump crashed the David S. Pumpkins cold open, which was worth 10 by itself (3 for the cold open, 2 for appearing and speaking, 5 for the recurring character), and he added Queen Mary Ghosts as the tour guide. It is his second-best total of the season, behind 25 in the premiere, and he has now opened all four Season 52 shows.

Runner-up: Mikey Day, 23 points. Two short of his Episode 3 MVP total and still second. The skeleton (+5), "Live from New York" (+5) and the cold open (+3) came before the monologue, and he spoke in four more sketches: Queen Mary Ghosts, Delta Disruptive, El Corazón Que No Siente and Plates.

Honorable mention: Veronika Slowikowska, 17 points. Her best night of the season. Her flubbed sign-off still earned the "Live from New York" bonus, and she added the monologue as Kelly Clarkson and PAW Patrol: SVU.

Studs and duds

Studs

• James Austin Johnson, 24 points. Episode MVP and only the second cast member this season to cash a break bonus.
• Mikey Day, 23 points. Three straight cold opens and 48 points in the last two weeks.
• Veronika Slowikowska, 17 points. After 11, 8 and 4, her best night yet.
• Sarah Sherman, 13 points. Five segments, all with lines, including the cold open as Lizzie Borden.
• Grace Reiter, 12 points. The rookie has gone 4, 4, 9 and 12, up or level every week.
• Wild-card owners. Six different wild cards hit for 45 points, triple the best of the first three weeks.

Duds

• Inde Navarrette, −2 for the break. She still scored 34 for her managers, but the break handed JAJ's owners 10.
• Colin Jost, 2 points. From 17 to 2. No political cold open meant no Hegseth, and the anchor point was all he got.
• Tommy Brennan, 2 points. Episode 3's breakout got one pre-tape: a talking-head testimonial as Kirk Munson in Delta Disruptive, about seven seconds on screen. He also turned up in the goodnights dressed as Sarah Sherman's Sarah Squirm.
• Andrew Dismukes, 2 points. One appearance, in the last sketch of the night.
• Gracie Abrams, 20 points. The pick bonus and nothing else, the second Season 52 musical guest held out of the sketches.

Trends: the season after four episodes

JAJ leads with 90 points, 18 ahead of Mikey Day (72). Jeremy Culhane (45) is third, and Ashley Padilla and Sarah Sherman (41 each) are tied for fourth. Cast scoring has gone 136, 138, 163 and now 174.

• It's a two-man race. JAJ and Day have finished first and second in three of four episodes, and the gap after Episode 3 (17) barely moved.
• Cast members are cracking up the hosts. Three of four Season 52 hosts have broken, and all three were caused by the cast: Day got Jalen Brunson and Shane Gillis, JAJ got Navarrette. Only Dakota Johnson got through clean.
• The cold open keeps growing. Three cast members in the premiere, then 7, 7 and now 9. JAJ has been in all four, Day in the last three.
• "Live from New York" is spreading out. JAJ said it in Episodes 1 and 2, Colin Jost in Episode 3, and this week it was split between Slowikowska and Day.
• Wild cards had their best week by far. 45 points, compared with 15, 10 and 10 in the first three episodes. Celebrity cameo has hit in three of four episodes. A puppet appears on camera and Food is central to a sketch have each hit twice.
• Settings rebounded. 14 points, matching Episode 3, after 4 and 20 in the first two. Infomercial is the only setting to hit in three episodes (2, 3 and 4).
• Rookies are rising. Grace Reiter has 29 points for the season. Saidah Belo-Osagie has 15 and got her first big role as Nicki Minaj.
• Host scoring held steady. Navarrette's 14 non-pick points match Dakota Johnson's and trail only Jalen Brunson's 15.
• Musical guests are a coin flip. KATSEYE and Rosalía appeared in sketches; Turnstile and Gracie Abrams did not. Two of four.
• History note. This was only the fifth SNL Halloween episode to air on October 31, after Donald Pleasence (1981), Dabney Coleman (1987), Catherine O'Hara (1992) and John Mulaney (2020).

Waiver wire: moves for Episode 5 (Druski / The Strokes)

• Start with confidence: James Austin Johnson and Mikey Day. Between them they have every cold open, every MVP and all three break bonuses this season.
• Pick up: Veronika Slowikowska. Her Katie Zacharia is a new political character; if it returns, it earns the recurring bonus.
• Pick up: Saidah Belo-Osagie. Same logic for her Nicki Minaj, and the show is finally giving her reps.
• Start: Sarah Sherman, Grace Reiter and Jeremy Culhane. All three were in the cold open and scored 12 or more.
• Hold: Colin Jost. His Hegseth carries him whenever politics leads the show, and this week it didn't.
• Bench: Tommy Brennan and Andrew Dismukes until they get regular sketch reps again.
• Looking ahead: John Mulaney hosts Episode 6 on November 14 with Phoebe Bridgers. It is his seventh time hosting.
• Wild cards: Celebrity cameo (three of four weeks) remains the best hold. Puppet, Food and Former cast member cameo are all live after this week.

Corrected Nov 8, 2026: the commissioner's Nov 7 rulings added Ben Marshall, Grace Reiter and Kenan Thompson to Cop Talk; Marshall, Marcello Hernández and Saidah Belo-Osagie to It's My Room Now; Kam Patterson, Thompson and Mikey Day to Upfront Heating & Air Conditioning; and Hernández to Saying Goodbye. Mikey Day finishes with 25, and the cast total is 163, not 143.

The game's defining play came in Green Eggs and Ham. Third-time host Shane Gillis flubbed a line, dropped an F-bomb on live television and broke. Mikey Day kept the sketch alive with an ad-libbed "you said a bad word," and the commissioner ruled that Day caused the break. That was worth +10 to Day. Gillis took −2 for breaking and another −2 for cursing, a 4-point hit for his managers.

That one sketch decided the night. Mikey Day finished with 25 points, three ahead of James Austin Johnson, and ended JAJ's run of five straight scored episodes on top of the cast leaderboard. JAJ still put up 22 behind RFK Jr. in the cold open and Kevin O'Leary at the Weekend Update desk, both ruled recurring.

The musical guest stole some of the spotlight too. Rosalía appeared in the Saying Goodbye sketch and had a line, scoring 11 points on top of her 20-point pick, while Colin Jost delivered his first solo "Live from New York."

Box score

The cast combined for 163 points, the best total of the season, even though Shane Gillis appeared in eight segments. A seven-person cold open did a lot of the work: every cast member in it banked at least 5 points before the monologue.

(R) = rookie.

Host and musical guest. Shane Gillis scored 32: 20 for the pick, 8 for appearances and 8 for speaking, minus 2 for breaking and 2 for cursing. Rosalía scored 31: 20 for the pick, 10 for appearing in Saying Goodbye and 1 for speaking. Drafting both was worth 63.

Settings (14 pts). Seven settings hit for 2 each: Talk Show and Car (Cop Talk), Historical and Office (Sneakers, a 1920 boardroom), Living Room (It's My Room Now), Infomercial (Upfront Heating & Air Conditioning) and Hospital/Doctor's Office (Saying Goodbye, a hospice room).

Wild cards (10 pts). Food is featured as a primary part of a sketch hit for Green Eggs and Ham, and Host sings outside the monologue hit for the It's My Room Now pre-tape. No celebrity cameo was reported, snapping that wild card's streak.

MVP: Mikey Day, 25 points

Day did it the same way he did in the premiere: by making the host laugh. The 10-point break bonus in Green Eggs and Ham was the single biggest play of the night, and it sat on top of a busy workload. Day was in the cold open (3) and spoke in six segments (12): the cold open, Cop Talk, Green Eggs and Ham, Sneakers, Upfront Heating & Air Conditioning and Chess Tournament.

He has now cashed a break bonus in two of three Season 52 episodes, both times on the host. Day moves to 49 points on the season, second behind JAJ.

Runner-up: James Austin Johnson, 22 points. Three points short. Before he appeared in a single regular sketch he had 10 points from the cold open as RFK Jr. Kevin O'Leary, first seen in the premiere's Shark Tank sketch, added 8 more at the Update desk, and two sketches with lines finished the job. He still leads the season with 66.

Honorable mention: Colin Jost, 17 points. His best night of the season. Jost earned the recurring bonus as Hegseth in consecutive cold opens and added 5 more for opening the show with his first solo "Live from New York."

Studs and duds

Studs

• Mikey Day, 25 points. Episode MVP and the first cast member other than JAJ to top a scored episode in our books. Break bonuses make him the league's highest-ceiling starter.
• Tommy Brennan, 11 points. The breakout of the night. Held to 2 in each of the first two episodes, Brennan landed the cold open and three sketches. Managers who stashed him finally got paid.
• Colin Jost, 17 points. He has gone 7, 12, 17, rising every week, and now sits third on the season.
• Ashley Padilla, 10 points. Her Update mom was ruled a recurring character, matching her 10 in Episode 2.
• Rosalía, 31 points. She is the second Season 52 musical guest to appear in a sketch, after KATSEYE in the premiere. Managers who picked her got 11 bonus points on top of the 20-point pick, the same total KATSEYE posted.

Duds

• Shane Gillis, −4 for the F-bomb. −2 for breaking and −2 for cursing in Green Eggs and Ham. Gillis still posted 32 points for his managers, but the slip cost them 4 and handed Mikey Day's owners 10.
• Kenan Thompson, 6 points. Three sketches and no bonus of any kind. The veteran has gone 13, 6, 6.
• Saidah Belo-Osagie, 2 points. One sketch, tied with Jane Wickline for the fewest of any non-anchor cast member.

Trends: the season after three episodes

JAJ has 66 points through three episodes, 17 more than Mikey Day (49) in second. Total cast scoring has gone 136, 138, then 163.

• The lead is safe, the streak is over. JAJ won Episodes 1 and 2 by 9 and 2 points. Mikey Day edged him by 3 in Episode 3, the first time in five scored episodes JAJ didn't finish on top.
• Day is the breaker-in-chief. Two break bonuses in three weeks (Brunson in the premiere, Gillis here) are worth 20 points on their own. No one else in the cast has caused a break this season.
• Jost is the season's quiet No. 3. Colin Jost has 36 points, 13 behind Mikey Day's 49. His Hegseth cold-open appearances make him one of the most reliable starters on the board.
• Kenan has stalled; Day has not. Kenan Thompson (13, 6, 6) has not topped 6 since the premiere. Mikey Day (16, 8, 25) bounced back with six segments and a break bonus.
• Big cold opens are the best weekly event. Seven cast members were in this week's cold open, after seven in Episode 2 and three in the premiere. Each one is worth at least 5 points.
• Rookie watch. Grace Reiter has 17 points for the season, five behind Andrew Dismukes (22). Saidah Belo-Osagie has 8.
• Musical guests are paying. Two of three Season 52 musical guests have appeared in a sketch. Last season's premiere guest, Doja Cat, scored 0 beyond her pick.
• Wild cards so far. Celebrity cameo hit in Episodes 1 and 2 but not 3. Host sings outside the monologue hit in Episodes 1 and 3.
• History note. Gillis was hired as a cast member in 2019 and dropped before his first episode. This was his third time hosting.

Waiver wire: moves for Episode 4 (Inde Navarrette / Gracie Abrams, Halloween)

• Start with confidence: James Austin Johnson, Mikey Day and Colin Jost. JAJ and Jost have appeared in the last two cold opens, and Day has appeared in every cold open but the premiere's, with a break bonus in two of three weeks.
• Pick up: Tommy Brennan, coming off his best night of the season.
• Pick up: Grace Reiter. Seventeen points in three weeks and rising usage make her the best rookie add.
• Start: Ashley Padilla. A recurring Update character gives her a floor, and a first-time actor host like Navarrette usually leans on the cast.
• Hold: Kenan Thompson. He has stalled, but a first-time host typically means more cast reps than a sketch-comic host like Gillis.
• Wild cards: It is the Halloween show, so Blood or vomit, Character death and A puppet appears on camera all deserve a look this week.

Corrected Nov 8, 2026: the commissioner's Nov 7 rulings added Andrew Dismukes and Ashley Padilla (no lines) to the cold open, Marcello Hernández to Press Your Luck, Jane Wickline and Veronika Slowikowska to Mean, Scary Girlfriend, and Sarah Sherman and Slowikowska to Guns for Women; Sherman was not in Mean, Scary Girlfriend. The cast total is 138, not 121.

James Austin Johnson made it two-for-two in Season 52. The reigning MVP led all cast members with 19 points, opening the show as Trump in a Republican midterm-ads cold open, delivering "Live from New York," and logging lines in two more sketches. That makes four straight scored episodes in our books where JAJ finished as the top cast scorer.

The headline, though, came in the monologue. Taylor Swift walked out to celebrate Dakota Johnson's birthday, cashing the Celebrity cameo wild card and, under league rules, a 10-point bonus for any team holding Swift as a musical guest pick. On a night when the cold open did most of the heavy lifting, that single walk-on was worth more than half the MVP's stat line.

The cast as a whole edged the premiere. The 17 active cast members combined for 138 points, two more than opening night, and the points moved around: the show leaned on a big political cold open and a crowded Weekend Update instead of the premiere's spread of sketch reps.

Box score

Seven cast members appeared in the cold open, which alone handed out 59 of the night's 138 cast points once the recurring-character and "Live from New York" bonuses are counted. Points are 3 for the cold open, 3 for a Weekend Update desk piece, 5 for a recurring character, and 2 for each sketch with a line.

(R) = rookie.

Host and musical guest. Dakota Johnson, in her third hosting stint, scored 34: 20 for the pick, 7 for appearances and 7 for speaking in the monologue and six sketches. Turnstile scored the 20-point pick bonus and nothing more. Drafting both was worth 54.

Settings (20 pts). Infomercial hit three times for 6, because ad parodies count: the midterm-ads cold open, Mean, Scary Girlfriend and Guns for Women. Hospital/Doctor's Office hit twice for 4 (Hospital Gossip, Amazing Tales of Truth). Fantasy and Film Parody (Throne of the Dragonborn), Game Show (Press Your Luck), Living Room (Guns for Women) and Social Media (Get Ready with Me) added 2 each.

Wild cards (10 pts, plus a cameo bonus). Celebrity cameo hit once for Taylor Swift in the monologue, and A puppet appears on camera hit for the dragon in Throne of the Dragonborn. Swift also triggers the 10-point cameo bonus for any team carrying her as a musical guest pick.

MVP: James Austin Johnson, 19 points

JAJ won without a big sketch night. Of his 19 points, 15 came before the monologue: 5 for appearing and speaking in the cold open, 5 for Trump as a recurring character and 5 for "Live from New York." The rest came from two late-show sketches, Get Ready with Me and Amazing Tales of Truth opposite Veronika Slowikowska.

That is the formula that has kept him on top. JAJ has now appeared in the cold open of four straight scored episodes, and as long as Trump stays in the news his floor is roughly 15 points before he appears in a single regular sketch.

Honorable mention: Marcello Hernández, 17 points. The premiere's biggest bust bounced all the way back. His Marco Rubio was ruled a recurring character, and he added two sketches and a Weekend Update desk piece as GTA's Jason opposite Mikey Day's Link.

Studs and duds

Studs

• Marcello Hernández, 17 points. From 0 in the premiere to second place. A three-category night (cold open, sketches, Update) is exactly the profile managers drafted him for. Those who held him were rewarded.
• Sarah Sherman, 14 points. Up from 6 in the premiere. Debbie Mush was ruled recurring, and four segments made this her busiest night of the season. Reviewers singled out her and Ashley Padilla in the women-led sketches.
• Colin Jost and Jeremy Culhane, 12 points each. Both cashed recurring political impressions in the cold open: Jost's Pete Hegseth and Culhane's JD Vance. Jost has now scored 7 or more in both Season 52 episodes.

Duds

• Mikey Day, 8 points. Half his premiere total. He got the cold open and an Update piece but no regular sketch.
• Kenan Thompson, 6 points. Three sketches, but no monologue, cold open or Update bonus to lift him. Less than half his premiere total.
• Ben Marshall, 4 points. He fronted the pre-show promos with Dakota Johnson but landed only two sketches. That is down from 10 in the premiere.
• Tommy Brennan, 2 points. Still a single sketch, the same as the premiere.

Trends: Episode 2 vs. the premiere

The cast scored 138 points, two more than the premiere, but the premiere's top three took the hit: JAJ, Mikey Day and Kenan Thompson went from 54 combined points to 33.

• Political cold opens spread the wealth. Seven cast members appeared in this week's cold open, compared with three in the premiere, and four of them earned recurring bonuses. A big political ensemble is the single best weekly event for deep rosters.
• Recurring politicians are the new bankers. JAJ's Trump, Jost's Hegseth, Marcello's Rubio and Culhane's JD Vance all earned the 5-point recurring bonus.
• Weekend Update got busier. Three desk pieces this week (Day and Marcello together, Patterson, and Sherman) versus two in the premiere. Update bonuses are trending toward a weekly 3-point floor for whoever owns a recurring desk character.
• Volatility is real for everyone below JAJ. Marcello swung from 0 to 17, Sherman from 6 to 14, while Day dropped from 16 to 8. Only JAJ has scored 15 or more in both Season 52 episodes.
• The host bar dipped slightly. Dakota Johnson scored 14 non-pick points, one fewer than Jalen Brunson's 15. Bad Bunny posted 16 in last year's premiere.
• Rookies doubled up. Grace Reiter and Saidah Belo-Osagie each appeared in two sketches, for 4 points apiece.

Waiver wire: moves for Episode 3 (Shane Gillis / Rosalía)

• Start with confidence: James Austin Johnson, the only player with 15 or more in both Season 52 episodes.
• Pick up: Colin Jost. A recurring Hegseth plus guaranteed desk duty gives him one of the highest floors in the league.
• Start: Marcello Hernández and Sarah Sherman. Both are back in the rotation with recurring characters on the board.
• Hold: Mikey Day and Kenan Thompson. Both had quiet nights, but a third-time host like Shane Gillis tends to anchor big ensemble sketches, which should mean more reps.
• Watch: Tommy Brennan. One sketch in each of the first two weeks is not yet a trend.
• Wild cards: Celebrity cameo has now hit in both Season 52 episodes. Host sings outside the monologue is worth a speculative look for a comedian host comfortable with musical pre-tapes.

Corrected Nov 8, 2026: the commissioner's Nov 7 rulings added Veronika Slowikowska to the cold open and Shark Tank: Respectacles, Sarah Sherman to Shark Tank: Respectacles, and Ben Marshall, Kam Patterson and Tommy Brennan to North High. The cast total is 136, not 121.

James Austin Johnson did what James Austin Johnson does on opening night: he took the first shot, the last shot, and most of the ones in between. The SNL Fantasy MVP posted a game-high 25 points in the Season 52 premiere, opening the show as Trump, delivering "Live from New York," and logging lines in six sketches. It is the third straight scored episode in our books where JAJ finished as the top cast scorer.

The night's biggest swing, though, belonged to Knicks point guard Jalen Brunson. Managers who picked him as host banked 35 points, and anyone who doubled up with KATSEYE as musical guest walked away with a 66-point head start before a single cast member was counted. On a night when the full cast combined for 136 points across 17 players, the host-and-guest pick was worth almost half the roster.

It was also a premiere played with a thinned-out bench. Seven players from last season's roster did not suit up, including perennial draft picks Bowen Yang, Chloe Fineman and Heidi Gardner. Two rookies, Grace Reiter and Saidah Belo-Osagie, got on the board in their debuts.

Box score

The top four cast scorers accounted for 66 of the cast's 136 points (49%). Seven of 17 cast members finished at 5 points or fewer.

(R) = rookie.

Host and musical guest. Jalen Brunson scored 35: 20 for the correct pick, 9 for appearances, 8 for speaking, minus 2 for breaking. KATSEYE scored 31: 20 for the pick, 10 for appearing in the Dream Academy pre-tape, 1 for speaking.

Settings (4 pts). Office (Office MVP) and Film Parody (North High) were the only approved settings to hit, at 2 each. Dream Academy and Shark Tank were ruled not to be Game Shows, and Weekend Update does not count as News Desk.

Wild cards (15 pts). Celebrity cameo hit twice for 10: Ramy Youssef as Mamdani in the cold open and Brunson's Knicks teammates (Towns, Bridges, Anunoby, Hart) in the monologue. Host sings outside the monologue added 5 for North High. Brunson stayed put for the monologue, so Host leaves the stage scored 0.

MVP: James Austin Johnson, 25 points

JAJ beat the second-place finisher by 9 points and matched the bottom eight cast members combined (25). He was the only cast member to collect three different bonuses in one night: cold open, recurring character and "Live from New York."

The floor is what makes him the league's safest first-round pick. The cold open plus a recurring Trump is worth a bankable bonus before the first commercial, and "Live from New York" stacks another 5 on top. Add six sketches with lines, the most of anyone in the cast, and the ceiling takes care of itself.

He was everywhere: Trump in the cold open, Office MVP, Men's Support Group, Parent-Teacher Conference, Kevin O'Leary in Shark Tank: Respectacles, and Old Friend. No other cast member appeared in more than five sketches.

Honorable mention: Mikey Day, 16 points. Day turned three sketches into the second-best night of the premiere because of a single 10-point swing. He got Brunson to break in Airport Massage Chairs, which was worth +10 to Day and −2 to Brunson. Critics thought the sketch was the night's weakest, which is a reminder that in this league, a dud on the air can still be a win on the scoreboard.

Studs and duds

Studs

• Jeremy Culhane, 12 points. The second-year player's Tucker Carlson returned to Weekend Update, earning both the recurring-character and Update bonuses. A recurring Update character is the closest thing this league has to a guaranteed target share.
• Ashley Padilla, 11 points. Freshly promoted to the main cast, Padilla opened the show as Natalie Harp and logged lines in four sketches. That is her best night in our scored episodes.
• Veronika Slowikowska, 11 points. A cold open and three sketches, nearly triple her Season 51 premiere total.
• Kenan Thompson, 13 points. The franchise's longest-tenured veteran keeps delivering steady volume. He played Stephen A. Smith in the monologue and spoke in five sketches, tied with Ben Marshall for second behind JAJ.
• Grace Reiter (R), 4 points. Modest numbers, but two sketches in her debut, including the well-reviewed Dream Academy and Old Friend. Rookies who get early reps tend to keep getting them.

Duds

• Marcello Hernández, 0 points. The biggest bust of the night. Marcello did not appear in an aired sketch, one year after scoring 15 in the Season 51 premiere. Managers who started him took a zero.
• Sarah Sherman, 6 points. A steep drop from 21 points in the Season 51 premiere and 23 in our Season 50 sample. Three sketches and no recurring character left her stranded.
• Cut for time. Young Rell's Crew and a Stella Lefty desk piece were cut. Cut sketches score nothing, so whoever was in them lost points that never made air.

Trends: premiere vs. premiere

The 15 cast members who played in both premieres scored 8 fewer points this year, and five of them lost ground. The cast as a whole put up 136 points, down from 158 in the Season 51 opener, which works out to 8.0 points per player versus 9.3 a year ago.

• JAJ's streak holds, but the margin is shrinking. He has been the top cast scorer in all three episodes we have scored (47 in S50E03, 33 in the S51 premiere, 25 tonight). Each total is lower than the last, so his edge now comes from the cold open more than raw volume.
• The cold open is the moat. JAJ has opened every scored episode. Mikey Day appeared in the cold open in both prior samples; this year Padilla and Slowikowska took those slots. Track who joins JAJ in the cold open each week; it is the most predictable bonus on the board.
• Three players are trending up across all three samples. Mikey Day (7, 11, 16), Kenan Thompson (7, 8, 13) and Ashley Padilla (0, 4, 11) have improved every time out.
• Weekend Update has opened up. Last premiere, Update pieces went to JAJ, Chloe Fineman, Bowen Yang and Kam Patterson. With Fineman and Yang gone, Culhane and Wickline took the desk. Expect Update to be the biggest source of new recurring-character points this season.
• Volatility warning. Sherman (23, 21, 6) and Marcello (2, 15, 0) have the widest swings on the roster. Neither is a safe weekly starter until their usage settles.
• History favors athlete hosts. Brunson is the fourth NBA player to host a season premiere, after Michael Jordan (1991), Charles Barkley (1993) and LeBron James (2007). His 15 non-pick points (9 appearances, 8 speaking, −2 break) were in line with Bad Bunny's 16 in last year's premiere.

Scoring note: the Season 50 and 51 reports were produced by an earlier version of the scoring engine and do not include host or guest pick bonuses, so compare host totals on non-pick points only.

Waiver wire: moves for Episode 2 (Dakota Johnson / Turnstile)

• Start with confidence: James Austin Johnson, Mikey Day, Kenan Thompson. All three have a cold open, monologue or break bonus in their profile and rising or steady usage.
• Pick up: Ashley Padilla. Main-cast promotion plus a cold open in Week 1 makes her the best add on the board.
• Pick up: Jeremy Culhane. A recurring Weekend Update character gives him a two-bonus path any week Tucker Carlson is in the news.
• Stash: Grace Reiter. Two sketches in her debut and strong reviews. Rookie reps tend to grow through the fall.
• Hold, don't drop: Marcello Hernández. One zero is not a trend, and he scored 15 in last year's premiere.
• Bench: Sarah Sherman until she gets a recurring character back on the air.
• Settings and wild cards: Celebrity cameo has hit in every episode we have scored, so it remains the best wild-card hold. Theater/Stage paid 4 in both of our earlier samples but blanked in the premiere; consider it a buy-low.